Last reviewed on · Updated
Ally Bank vs SoFi: Which Online Bank Is Better?
Quick verdict
Choose SoFi if you have a regular direct deposit and want checking and savings in one app. SoFi's best savings rate usually depends on direct deposit or other qualifying activity.
Choose Ally if you want a savings rate with no activity requirements, a wider range of CDs, savings “buckets” and phone support that has historically been available around the clock.
At-a-glance comparison
| Feature | Ally Bank | SoFi |
|---|---|---|
| Who holds your money | Ally Bank (Member FDIC) | SoFi Bank, N.A. (Member FDIC) |
| Savings APY at our April 2026 review | 4.35%, no activity requirement | 4.60% with qualifying direct deposit; lower without it |
| Checking interest | Small, tiered rate on the Spending Account | Up to 0.50% on the checking balance |
| Monthly fee / minimum balance | $0 / none | $0 / none |
| Overdraft fees | None (Ally removed overdraft fees in 2021) | None; no-fee overdraft coverage for eligible members |
| Early direct deposit | Yes, up to 2 days early | Yes, up to 2 days early |
| ATMs | Allpoint network, plus reimbursement of some out-of-network fees | Allpoint network |
| CDs | Yes (several types, including no-penalty) | No |
| Savings organization | Savings buckets and automatic savings tools | Vaults inside the savings account |
| Other products in the same app | Investing and auto financing | Investing, personal loans, student loans, credit card |
Rates were recorded at our last review (April 2026) and are variable. Both banks change their APYs as market rates move, so check ally.com and sofi.com for today's figures.
Interest rates: compare the conditions, not just the headline
At our last review SoFi advertised the higher savings APY, but only for members with qualifying direct deposits (or another activity requirement SoFi sets). Without that, SoFi's savings rate was much lower. Ally's savings rate was a little lower than SoFi's top rate, but it applied to every customer with no conditions.
The checking side is very different. Some older comparisons say SoFi pays its top savings rate on checking too. That is not how the account works: SoFi's checking balance earns a much smaller rate than its savings balance. Ally's Spending Account also pays only a small amount of interest. With either bank, keep the money you don't need day to day in savings.
Worked example (illustrative only): on a $10,000 balance, a 0.25-percentage-point APY difference is worth about $25 a year. If you'd have to change your direct deposit just to get the higher rate, that may not be worth the effort. Use our savings calculator with today's actual rates.
Fees: effectively a tie
- Neither bank charges a monthly maintenance fee or requires a minimum balance on its core checking and savings accounts.
- Neither charges overdraft fees. Ally dropped them entirely in 2021, and SoFi offers no-fee overdraft coverage to eligible members (limits apply).
- Both use the Allpoint ATM network. Ally has also reimbursed a limited amount of other banks' ATM fees each statement cycle, which helps if you often use out-of-network ATMs.
- Less common services such as outgoing wires can carry fees at either bank. Check each bank's fee schedule.
Customer service
Ally has long advertised phone support around the clock, alongside chat and secure messaging. SoFi offers phone and chat support with set hours. If being able to call a person at 2 a.m. matters to you, Ally has the edge. If you mostly use the app, either will work. Confirm current support hours on each bank's contact page.
Account structure and extras
Ally Bank
- Separate checking (Spending Account), savings, money market and CD products
- Savings buckets and automatic savings tools such as round-ups and recurring transfers
- Overdraft protection by transferring from savings
- Has operated as Ally Bank since 2009 (formerly GMAC Bank)
SoFi
- Checking and savings combined in one account, with Vaults for savings goals
- Banking, investing and lending in one app
- Has advertised member benefits such as financial planning sessions and rate discounts on some loans. Check SoFi's site for what currently applies.
- Bank charter since 2022 (SoFi Bank, N.A.)
Who should choose which bank?
Choose Ally Bank if:
- You don't have (or don't want to move) a direct deposit
- You want CDs alongside savings
- You like organizing savings into buckets
- Phone support at any hour matters to you
- You sometimes use out-of-network ATMs
Choose SoFi if:
- You have a direct deposit you can send to SoFi
- You want checking and savings in one account
- You already use, or plan to use, SoFi's loans or investing
- You're comfortable mostly using the app and chat
Bottom line
If your paycheck can go to SoFi, SoFi's all-in-one account usually gives the higher savings rate. If you want a strong rate with no conditions, more savings tools and CDs, Ally is the simpler choice. Neither charges monthly fees, so you can also open both, for example SoFi for everyday spending and Ally for savings goals and CDs.
En resumen: ¿Ally Bank o SoFi, cuál es mejor?
SoFi conviene si puede recibir su depósito directo (nómina) en SoFi: su mejor tasa de ahorro suele depender de ese requisito, y combina cuenta corriente y de ahorro en una sola aplicación. La cuenta corriente paga mucho menos interés que la de ahorro.
Ally Bank conviene si quiere una buena tasa de ahorro sin requisitos, certificados de depósito (CD), “buckets” para organizar sus ahorros y atención telefónica amplia.
Ninguno cobra comisiones mensuales ni de sobregiro, y ambos están asegurados por la FDIC hasta $250,000 por depositante. Las tasas cambian con frecuencia: confírmelas en el sitio web de cada banco antes de abrir una cuenta.
Related reading
Editorial note: this page is general information, not financial advice. See the editorial disclaimer for the full statement. Rates, fees and account terms change without notice — confirm current details with each bank before you open an account.